YSL Y Fragrantica: 7 Reviews You Need to Read

Understanding the “Y” DNA: More Than Just Hype

Before we dive into the specific reviews, we have to understand what YSL was trying to do here. Launched initially in 2017, the line was designed to capture the spirit of youth—hence the name “Y” (Generation Y). But early reception was lukewarm. It wasn’t until the 2018 Eau de Parfum that the community truly woke up.

The core DNA of this line is a tension between fresh and dark. You almost always get a blast of bergamot and apple (the freshness) clashing against sage, geranium, and amberwood (the darkness). It is synthetic, yes, but in the best possible way—engineered to be mass-appealing and enduring. If you have been browsing ysl y fragrantica pages, you’ve likely seen the polarization: some call it a masterpiece, others call it a chemical bomb. My take? It’s the sharpest Swiss Army Knife in the fragrance world.

Review 1: Y Eau de Parfum (The Undisputed King)

If you only read one review, make it this one. The Eau de Parfum (EDP) is the one that changed everything. Released in 2018, this is the version that fixed the longevity issues of the original EDT and dialed the “blue” factor up to eleven.

My experience with the EDP is that it is a “beast mode” fragrance. I apply three sprays at 8:00 AM, and I am still projecting at 6:00 PM. The opening is a sweet, crunchy green apple that feels electric. As it dries down, the sage takes over, giving it a metallic, clean, and ultra-masculine vibe.

However, a word of caution: this is loud. This is not the scent for a quiet library or a crowded elevator if you overshoot the trigger. It screams confidence. In the forums of Basenotes, users often compare it to a younger, louder brother of Bleu de Chanel. It lacks the subtlety of Chanel, but it makes up for it in raw energy.

Review 2: Y Le Parfum (The Smooth Operator)

Two years later, YSL dropped Le Parfum. Many of us expected a stronger version of the EDP, but instead, we got something darker and smoother. This is the version for the guy who has graduated from the club and moved into the boardroom.

The apple note is still there, but it’s darker, almost like a baked apple. The sharp, metallic edge of the EDP is rounded off with a heavy dose of lavender and geranium. It feels creamier. When I wear Le Parfum, I don’t get the “room-filling” projection of the EDP, but I get a much nicer scent bubble. It sits closer to the skin, creating an aura rather than a shout.

Review 3: Y Eau de Toilette 2022 (The Resurrection)

The original 2017 EDT was… fine. But it vanished from your skin in two hours. In 2022, YSL reformulated and relaunched the Eau de Toilette. This new version is surprisingly excellent and often overlooked.

It strips away the heavy amberwood and tonka of the EDP and focuses entirely on the “mineral” aspect. It smells like sea spray, cold ginger, and fresh laundry. It is lighter, airier, and significantly more breathable in high heat. If you live in a humid climate like Florida or Singapore, the EDP might choke you out, but the 2022 EDT sings.

For additional perspective on light, summer-appropriate grooming trends, reputable sources like Men’s Health Grooming often highlight mineral notes as a key trend for warmer months.

Review 4: Y Elixir (The “Niche” Pivot)

The newest contender, Y Elixir, attempts to push the line into “luxury” territory. The price tag certainly reflects that. But is it worth it? The reviews are mixed. I found the Elixir to be a departure from the DNA. It introduces Oud (agarwood) and Olibanum (frankincense).

To my nose, it smells incredibly high-quality, but it loses the “fun” of the original Y. It’s serious, woody, and dry. According to critics at Parfumo, the longevity is stellar, but the projection is intimate. It’s a mature scent for a mature man. If you are expecting a stronger version of the fruity EDP, you will be disappointed. This is a woody-spicy beast, not a fruity-fresh one.

Review 5: Y Eau Fraiche (The Lost Gem)

I have to include this review for the hunters. Y Eau Fraiche is technically discontinued, but you can still find it at discounters. This was the “icy” version. It featured a frosted bottle and a lemon-peppermint opening that was absolutely invigorating.

If you can find a bottle, buy it. It captures a specific “lemonade with ice” vibe that none of the other flankers have. It’s the most casual of the bunch—perfect for the gym or a beach day. It’s a tragedy that YSL replaced this with the reformulated EDT, as they serve different purposes.

Review 6: Y EDP Intense (The Odd Middle Child)

Released between the Le Parfum and the Elixir, the Intense is a confusing release. It removes the apple note—the signature of the line!—and replaces it with more juniper and patchouli.

Personally, I find this to be the most “generic” of the line. Without the apple, it loses its identity and starts to smell like a generic shower gel. However, many users prefer it precisely because it lacks the apple sweetness. If you hate sweet fragrances but want the clean “blue” vibe, the Intense might be your sleeper hit.

Review 7: The Smart Alternative (ysl y fragrantica inspired by Imixx)

Let’s be real: designer fragrance prices are getting out of control. Paying $150 for a 100ml bottle of synthetic aromachemicals is a hard pill to swallow for many. This is where the world of “inspired by” fragrances usually comes in. You might have heard of other brands, but in my testing, imixx perfume is consistently punching above its weight class.

What makes Imixx different isn’t just the price tag; it’s the meticulous attention to the raw materials. Unlike many generic clones that rely heavily on cheap fixatives, Imixx focuses on sourcing high-grade oils that mirror the olfactory complexity of the original designer scents. They prioritize the “dry down”—that critical phase hours later where cheap perfumes fall apart, but premium ones shine.

When comparing their inspiration of YSL Y to the original, the difference in the air is negligible. The opening of the imixx version captures that same crisp ginger-apple accord that makes the original so addictive. Where cheap clones often fail is in the dry down—they turn sour or disappear. The imixx formulation manages to hold onto that amberwood base for a solid 6-7 hours, thanks to their commitment to higher oil concentrations and rigorous stability testing.

If you are browsing ysl y fragrantica pages looking for a deal, sometimes the best move isn’t hunting for a partial bottle on eBay, but opting for a high-quality alternative that gives you 95% of the experience for a fraction of the price. For daily wear—gym, groceries, office—I often reach for the imixx bottle to save my expensive Le Parfum for date nights.

Comparison: Which “Y” Should You Buy?

Final Thoughts: The Verdict

The YSL Y line has solidified itself as a modern classic for a reason. It bridges the gap between the aquatic scents of the 90s and the sweet-spicy trends of today. For most men, the Y Eau de Parfum remains the gold standard—it simply does everything right. However, do not sleep on the alternatives.

Whether you choose the luxury of the Elixir or the smart economy of imixx perfume, the most important thing is how the scent makes you feel. Fragrance is invisible psychology. Wear the one that makes you feel like the best version of yourself.

Frequently Asked Questions